How Making the First Offer Gives You the Edge in Contract Negotiations

Negotiating contracts is both an art and a science. Savvy entrepreneurs and lawyers know that subtle psychological principles can often make the difference between closing a great deal and walking away disappointed. One of the most powerful tools you can use is the anchoring effect—a cognitive bias that influences decision-making by using the first piece of information presented as a reference point.

At LawHax, we’ve embedded negotiation strategies like the anchoring effect directly into our contract templates to give you an edge. Here's how you can use it to secure better terms in your next contract negotiation.

What Is the Anchoring Effect?

The anchoring effect is a cognitive bias where people rely too heavily on the first piece of information they receive when making decisions. This initial information, called an "anchor", becomes a reference point that significantly influences subsequent judgments, even if the original information is irrelevant or inaccurate.

For example:

• In negotiations, if one party starts with a high number, it influences the other party’s perception of value, even if the figure is unreasonable.
• Similarly, if the first draft of a contract contains unfavorable terms, these terms can become the starting point for discussions, giving the drafter an advantage.

By understanding and leveraging this bias, you can control the narrative and secure better outcomes.

‍

How to Leverage Anchoring in Contract Negotiations

1. Be the First to Present Terms

In negotiations, the first mover always sets the anchor. If you draft the initial version of a contract, you frame the discussion around your preferred terms. This gives you control over:

• Payment terms
• Delivery schedules
• Liability clauses
• Intellectual property rights

Actionable Tip: Use LawHax’s contract templates to create polished, professional drafts that subtly incorporate favorable terms for your business. By presenting the first version, you set the tone for the negotiation.

‍

2. Anchor High (or Low) Based on Your Objective

If you're negotiating pricing, start with a higher-than-expected number to make concessions feel generous while still landing where you want. For terms like penalties or liability caps, set them conservatively so the counterparty feels relieved to negotiate them up slightly.

Example:

• High Anchor: Propose a $50,000 project fee knowing you’re comfortable with $40,000. When you “compromise” at $40,000, the client feels they’ve won a discount.
• Low Anchor: If discussing liability caps, propose limiting liability to $10,000. Even if the other side negotiates it higher, you’ve set a favorable baseline.

Tip: In LawHax templates, look for pre-drafted clauses that set strong anchors (e.g., fair payment terms, low liability caps) without appearing unreasonable.

‍

3. Use Anchoring to Frame Value

Anchors don’t just apply to numbers—they also influence perceptions of fairness, effort, and risk. If a contract highlights how much effort your team will invest or the risks you’re taking, it justifies more favorable terms.

Example:
In a service agreement, explicitly outline your scope of work:

"This engagement includes 100+ hours of specialized legal research, custom deliverables, and ongoing support."

This framing makes higher fees feel justified and reasonable, anchoring the client’s perception of value at a high level.

‍

4. Countering a Bad Anchor

What if the other side anchors first with unfavorable terms? Don’t panic. The key is to:

1. Reframe the conversation: Acknowledge the anchor but immediately redirect the discussion to your preferred terms.
   • Example: “I see where you’re coming from, but a more industry-standard approach would be...”
2. Introduce a new anchor: Replace their initial anchor with one more favorable to you.

‍

How LawHax Templates Give You an Edge

Negotiating effectively requires more than psychological insights—it demands well-structured contracts that set you up for success. Here’s how LawHax’s templates help you leverage the anchoring effect:

1. Strategically Drafted Terms: Pre-drafted clauses act as anchors, setting the negotiation baseline in your favor.
2. Customizable Language: Adjust the tone and specifics to align with your negotiation goals.
3. Expert Notes: Each template includes tips on using cognitive biases, like anchoring, to strengthen your position.

Real-Life Success Stories

• Startup Funding Negotiation: A founder used a LawHax term sheet template to propose an investor-friendly valuation while anchoring equity at 15% instead of the 25% the investor initially sought. The deal closed at 18%.
• Service Agreement Win: A consultant leveraged a pre-drafted LawHax contract to anchor fees at $10,000/month, far above what she would have proposed without guidance.

‍

Turn the Tables in Your Favor

The anchoring effect isn’t just a psychological quirk—it’s a powerful negotiation tool. By setting the first anchor or countering an unfavorable one, you can guide discussions toward better outcomes.

With LawHax’s contract templates, you’ll not only anchor terms to your advantage but also streamline the entire process with expert-backed resources.

👉 Ready to negotiate like a pro? Download our free contract templates today and start setting the terms that work for you.

‍